Slideshow image

Introduction

I’m a hot dog connoisseur. Nathan’s Hot Dogs are great, but I’m partial to Hebrew National. They “answer to a higher authority”—or so says their tagline. They are a kosher food company, meaning they comply with the dietary requirements of Jews worldwide. Do you think God would be ok with me eating “kosher food” even though I’m not Jewish? What about halal foods? It’s a similar principle.

Or imagine walking into a grocery store, and the only meat for sale is meat that was first offered to a fake god at a pagan temple down the street. That probably sounds strange to you. But for the Christians in a city called Corinth, this was a real, everyday problem. Could they eat that meat? Was it okay? Or was it a sin? That question split the church. Some people said, “Of course we can eat it. Those gods aren’t even real.” Other people said, “No way. That meat reminds me of my old life. I can’t touch it.” Paul writes this whole chapter to answer them. But notice something. He does not start by talking about the meat. He starts by talking about love. And that is the key to the whole thing.

Our big idea today is simple: love shapes our liberty in membership. Your freedom is real. But in God’s family, love gets to shape how you use it. Let’s walk through three things Paul shows us.

The Danger of “Puffed Up” Knowledge (vv. 1–3)

Observation

Look at how Paul opens. He says, “We know that ‘all of us possess knowledge.’ This ‘knowledge’ puffs up, but love builds up” (v. 1). Then he adds, “If anyone imagines that he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know. But if anyone loves God, he is known by God” (vv. 2–3). Did you catch that? The very first thing Paul warns about is not the meat. It’s pride. It’s knowledge that makes a person puffed up.

Historical Context

Corinth was a smart, proud city. It’s not just the Sin City of the ancient world, filled with decadence. It was full of teachers, debates, big ideas, too. The “strong” Christians who converted had already figured it out. Sigmund Freud once said, “Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.” Corinthian Christians knew the truth: idols are fake, God made all food, so sometimes a steak is just a steak. And they were right about the facts. But being right made them feel bigger than they truly were. They started looking down on the brothers and sisters who still felt nervous about that meat. Their correct knowledge had a side effect. It made them proud.

Interpretation/Illustration

Why does the Three Little Pigs come to mind? We need something sturdy that’s going to stand strong in storms and problems. That’s not what flimsy, puffed-up things do. Think about the word “puffed up.” Paul is picturing a balloon. A balloon looks big, but it’s full of nothing but air. One little pin and it pops. That’s what pride does to us. Knowledge can blow us up like a balloon, all show and no strength. Its perspective is limited to our scope, our field of vision.

But love is different. Love “builds up,” like bricks stacked to make a strong house. One puffs you up with air. The other builds something that persists through trials and relational fallout. Paul says it even sharper in another letter: “If I…understand all mysteries and all knowledge… but have not love, I am nothing” (1 Corinthians 13:2). You can be the smartest person in the room and still be nothing without love.

And here’s the best part. Our greatest treasure was never how much we know about God. It’s that God knows us. “If anyone loves God, he is known by God” (v. 3).Let that sink in.

There is a type of person in the room that can be known by God without God being their friend and rescuer. But to be loved by God? And to know that God is for you? Pledges himself to you? The God of the universe knows you by name! That’s the real boast. Not what’s in your head, but that you belong to Him.

Application

So here’s the first question for us. When you’re sure you’re right about something, what does it do to your heart? Does it make you gentle, or does it make you proud? It is possible to win the argument and lose your brother. This week, before you correct anyone, ask yourself: am I trying to build them up, or just prove I’m right? Our ultimate boast isn’t what we know. It’s that God knows us.

The Vulnerability of the Weak (vv. 4–8)

Observation

Paul agrees with the facts. He writes, “an idol has no real existence,” and “there is no God but one” (v. 4). For us, there is one God and one Lord, Jesus Christ (v. 6). The strong were correct in this instance—and oftentimes are correct even today. But then comes the turn. “However, not all possess this knowledge. But some, through former association with idols, eat food as really offered to an idol, and their conscience, being weak, is defiled” (v. 7). So there are two groups in the church. The strong, who feel free. And the weak, whose conscience still aches.

Historical Context

Who were these “weak” believers? They were people who had spent their whole lives, maybe thirty years or more, worshiping false gods in those temples. They had bowed down, prayed, and given sacrifices to idols. Now they were saved. They were new in Christ. But they can still smell that temple meat, and it still sets off alarms inside them. In their gut, eating it felt like going back to their old sin. They want more than anything to be faithful to Jesus and forsake idols.

Interpretation/Illustration

Now, we have to be careful here, because we use the word “weak” the wrong way today. When we say someone is weak, we usually mean they have no willpower or they fold under pressure. That is not what Paul means. A “weak conscience” is:

  • First, a weak conscience is tied to a person’s past. They cannot easily separate what they’re doing now from the life they used to live. For the Corinthians, the meat wasn’t a morally neutral act. They were going back to their previous spiritual slave masters.

  • Second, a weak conscience doesn’t bend much. The strong believer can do the

    biblical calculus: idols are fake, plus God made all food, equals I’m free to eat. The weak believer doesn’t have that elasticity yet. Their moral alarm is extra sensitive. It goes off even in the gray areas, the things the Bible doesn’t clearly call right or wrong.

  • Third, and this is the big one, it is dangerous to push someone to violate their conscience. Paul says elsewhere, “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (Romans 14:23). So if a weak believer truly thinks something is sin and does it anyway, they’ve actually sinned against God, even if the thing itself was harmless. Paul also says, “nothing is unclean in itself, but it is unclean for anyone who thinks it unclean” (Romans 14:14). Their conscience becomes “defiled,” and that can wreck their faith.

  • Fourth, this isn’t meant to be forever. The goal is for the weak to grow strong

    over time as the Holy Spirit shapes them. But you don’t make a weak person

    strong by forcing them to do the very thing that scares them. You don’t help a

    recovering alcoholic by handing them a beer.

Application

So, church family, here’s the heart of it: When your brother’s alarm is ringing, you can’t downplay the alarm that goes off in their head and heart by poking fun at it or ignoring it. A weak conscience is not a joke. It’s a fragile, load-bearing pillar in someone’s faith. As Andrew Wilson put it, “Love trumps freedom.” Your posture this week is to look around and see who in your life is still carrying the baggage of their past? Your job isn’t to fix their conscience. Your job is to help them feel safe by teaching them and helping them rehearse how the gospel is the load-bearing foundation of their salvation and soul.

The Radical Surrender of Rights (vv. 9–13)

Observation

Now Paul lands the plane. “Take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak” (v. 9). If a weak brother sees you eating in the idol’s temple, he might copy you, go against his own conscience, and be destroyed, “the brother for whom Christ died” (v. 11). Then Paul says something that cuts to the heart of the issue: “sinning against your brothers and wounding their conscience when it is weak, you sin against Christ” (v. 12). And he ends with his own promise: “if food makes my brother stumble, I will never eat meat, lest I make my brother stumble” (v. 13). Paul says he would give up meat forever rather than trip a brother up.

Historical Context

Paul isn’t asking the church to do something he won’t do himself. He lays down his own rights first. And this fits a warning Jesus gave. Jesus said, “Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him if a great millstone were hung around his neck and he were thrown into the sea” (Mark 9:42). Jesus is talking about children here in this passage, but its applicable to young ones in the faith, too. That’s how seriously God takes it when we trip up a young believer.

Hundreds of years later, the church leader Augustine taught the same thing. He said the strong, even when nothing bothers their own conscience, are still commanded to hold back so they don’t cause a weaker person to stumble. It’s not a new idea; it runs all through Scripture.

Interpretation/Illustration

Now, we don’t buy idol meat at our stores. So what is our “idol meat”? Let me give you four real ones:

  • First, alcohol. The strong believer says, “Jesus made wine. The Bible only bans

    drunkenness.” True. But sitting near you might be a recovering alcoholic, or

    someone saved from a home wrecked by drinking. For them, a drink is not

    neutral. It’s the scent of their past pain. Love says, “I can drink, but I’ll happily

    order a Coke to keep my brother safe.”

  • Second, entertainment and media. The strong believer says, “I can watch a gritty

    show and filter out the bad parts.” Maybe you can; I’m not that strong. But next to you sits someone fighting a daily battle against lust or pornography. When you casually recommend that show, they think, “Well, if they watch it, it must be fine,” and they get pulled back into bondage. Love says, “I won’t flaunt my freedom if it could spiritually bankrupt someone else.”

  • Third, holidays like Halloween. The strong believer knows ghosts aren’t real and

    sees harmless fun. But some members were saved out of the occult, or out of

    strict, religious backgrounds, and their consciences are troubled by it. Love says, “I don’t have to agree with you, but I will never mock your conscience or force you to join in.”

  • Fourth, aggressive politics. The strong believer feels free to post sharp political

    memes online. But a new believer from a different background sees it and thinks,

    “To follow Jesus, I guess I have to adopt this exact anger.” And it becomes a wall

    between them and the Gospel. Love says, “I’ll give up winning the argument

    online if it risks losing my brother’s soul in the pew.”

Application

Paul calls us to a radical surrender. Not of our beliefs, but of our rights when love asks for it. “You were called to freedom, brothers. Only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another” (Galatians 5:13). Real freedom is the power to lay something down for someone you love.

Conclusion

HBC, your freedom is a beautiful thing. We’re about to celebrate the 250th Anniversary of the USA. We love freedom. And in Christ, we’re the freest people on the planet! But if your freedom becomes the very thing that drags your brother or sister back into their old life of sin, it stops being freedom. It becomes a weapon. And meaningful membership means we drop our weapons to protect our family. That’s what Jesus did. He had every right in heaven, and He laid them all down to save you. He didn’t cling to His freedom. He surrendered it on a cross, for the weak, for you and me.

So carry this home this week: What freedom will love ask you to lay down? Maybe it’s a drink. Maybe it’s a show. Maybe it’s the last word in an argument. Whatever it is, remember the rule that holds it all together. Love trumps freedom.

For more blog posts from Pastor Tim, check out The Bitz Blitz